Answer: It's a Potato Masher! Congratulations to johnbellm who got the answer right on his first guess! Thanks to everyone who took a shot, I'd have to give dakalvia the prize for most...uh...innovative!
I know we did one of these rather recently, but I couldn't resist when I saw this one. Check it out and guess in the comments. So far lujomika and jessica guessed the last one
correctly on the first try, so we'll see how this one goes! Happy Guessing!