One Laptop Per Child, and one for you too


by sharonna Nov 8, 2007 fileunderFound in Computers


Originally unveiled to the international development world as the $100 Laptop, later upped to a more reasonable $175 (as Amanie has written here), the One-Laptop-per-Child (OLPC) initiative has decided that beginning November 12, it will now offer a "Give 1, Get 1" deal for North American residents.

The price tag?

For $399 you will receive an XO-1 laptop at home and also donate one to a child in a developing nation. Obviously this is a smart marketing ploy and will make all the supporters of the project giddy that they can do good and have a new toy at the same time. It is still important to question the efficacy of this laptop to bridge the digital divide and provide education to needy children.

On top of it all, EA announced today that they are donating the original version of SimCity to each computer in the OLPC initiative, which the company claims is the first time a major video game publisher has gifted a game to the world. It apparently will "provide children with a way to engage with computers while learning decision-making skills".

Although a generous donation, I am highly skeptical of how this additional software actually follows the OLPC mandate. How can children learn from it when the environment of SimCity is so drastically removed from their lifestyles? Where is the line drawn between pure knowledge and corporate sponsored knowledge? It seems to me that Nicholas Negroponte's vision is slowly being manipulated into a self-gratifying project of the developed world.

Comments

1.  avatar Omar said:

The XO-1 always had games built in, though they weren't given much attention since they were of the crummy edutainment variety. I've made my thoughts on the XO-1 known elsewhere (in the comments of the report). I think it's an interesting angle that the original vision is being latched upon by PR-baiting corporate types. And considering the difficulties the OLPC has gone through in recent times, can you blame them for compromising?

And I mean come on. Sim City is one of the all-time classics! Will Wright's masterpiece is STILL relevant, playable and enjoyable to people across all walks of life. I have a strong belief in the value of entertainment to distract people away from the hardships in their lives. I'd rather somebody take up video games as a form of coping than drugs or other destructive mechanisms.

Now, whether or not SimCity is actually PLAYABLE to the children is a different matter. I highly doubt that EA will be localizing the game for all of these different languaegs. And that will be the true test of their sincerity. If the game is localized into a language the recipient children will know, then it's genuine. If they stick with the stock languages, well then it's obviously just a PR stunt.
Nov 08, 2007 9:34pm
2.  avatar dialupinternetuser said:

Sim City 2000 was the best (Priscilla cheat), but personally I think we should give them water before a computer.
Nov 10, 2007 11:08pm
3.  avatar dialupinternetuser said:

There is a TV commercial about the deal with the Chinese guy from Heroes.

Nov 24, 2007 11:17am
Some HTML is allowed. Your comments remain editable after you post.