Amanie,
Yeah, I was thinking of a checkbox / radio button option as well. It would definitely be more neutral.
If you choose the radio button / checkbox way, the only thing I'd suggest is to rethink the count. Right now, the count is nicely tied to the color of True/False. So it's easy to see in the first 'pro' that the +10 is for True as it is green. If you make both TRUE/FALSE boxes have the same color checkmark, you would lose that clarity.
A way around that might be to display the count to the right of FALSE if 'FALSE" is winning. But I don't know how that would play out. Never used a UI like that before. Might be worth a shot to keep things really neutral.