Logitech Extreme 3D Pro

The Logitech Extreme 3D Pro is a no frills joystick in an already crowded market. There have been complaints that this joystick is plagued with problems and design flaws and has a lifespan of only a few months.

Logitech Extreme 3D Pro
MSRP $29.99
Release date January, 2006
Brand Logitech
love it
want it
have it
tag it

Pros & Cons

ProSCORE
3 reviews
22
negative
mixed
positive
0 positive
1 mixed
2 negative

[i] How is the ProSCORE calculated?

show me!

Pros:
Do you agree?
Comfortable grip for right handers
+1agreedisagree

Nice button motion
0agreedisagree

Cons:
Do you agree?
Bad Design (Design flaws)
+3agreedisagree

Cheap Parts
+2agreedisagree

Warranty shipping cost more than the product
+1agreedisagree

Stops functioning correctly after a period of time
+1agreedisagree


3 people added to this review by submitting or voting on pros and cons. Add your say!

Details

Submit a link

This report was started December 29, 2007 at 5:08 am by Charon9
with the last edit occurring June 14, 2009 at 10:35 pm by j.vaughan
This page has been viewed 1705 times, with 21 edits by 5 contributors.
See the full report history »

Competitors

Logitech Extreme 3D Pro is ranked 2nd among it's competitors.  See the top picks in Joysticks »

Suggest a new competitor to add to the list of competing products.
If the product hasn't yet been added to ProductWiki, submitting it here will also start the product report.

Comments

1.  avatar Charon9 said:

I am currently on my 2nd of these joysticks, and I would not be on the 2nd except that it was a Christmas present. There are hundreds if not thousands of posts on the internet talking about a host of problems with this product. Knowing a bit about electronics I took mine apart to see if I could figure out what was causing them.

First: The Rheostats used in the joystick are so cheap you buy them by the pound. This means they are highly inaccurate and prone to dropouts (or infinity resistances). What this means to the end user is calibration problems, or joysticks that will not stay calibrated as the resistance just went outside the learned range.

Second: The Joystick has a reported problem of the 'twist' or 'rudder' not working after a while. This is the result of a design flaw in the rheostat assembly that allows a section of it to break off. Once broken you can forget any type of glue to fix it as it is hopeless. Recalibrate it, live with the limit, or throw it away.

Third: Replacing the Rheostats with good quality products is impossible, or mostly so. They are molded into the assemblies and there is not enough there to even work with on replacing them.

Overall View: Total trash, spend half the money on a no-named stick, that will live just as long, and consider your money well spent.
Dec 29, 2007 5:19am
2.  avatar squalorking said:

Tis true, what Charon9 says. I really liked the way mine felt, but it lasted a month.
Dec 31, 2007 11:33am
3.  avatar j.vaughan said:

I love this joystick and yes I suffer from the calibration issues as well.

I think I have a solution for everyone. Just play around with it. If it doesn't automatically recalibrate with the first few times of un-plugging and plugging it back in then...

try yawing it to the right just a little bit to "trick" the calibration while simultaneously plugging it in....

A few times of trying this and you'll be able to get the z-axis almost to the center. However, you will often notice that sometimes the z-axis (rudder) will jump all the way to the left when you plug in the joystick with very little effort. I've found that when this happens the calibration sensor has "kicked-in". Simply un-plug and plug it back in to check and see if it sets the proper calibration on its own (no yawing involved.)

Note, you have to have the windows game controller window open to see if the axis is centered or not. Most of you should know what I'm talking about. In addition, I never install / don't need to use the default logitech software for the joystick.

I've had this joystick approaching for 2 years now and so far this trick has always worked. So what if I have to play with it a little bit, the springs and feel of the joystick is still great despite some calibration issues compared to many of the other joysticks I've used, the majority of which have low durability as well.
Jun 14, 2009 10:34pm
Some HTML is allowed. Your comments remain editable after you post..

Reviews

Sort by: Most helpful  •  Newest  •  Most positive

Charon9

avatar
December 29, 2007
approved
reviewer
ProSCORE
0
negative
mixed
positive
0 pros
3 cons
have ithave it
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

Pros

Did not agree with any pros

Cons

  • Bad Design (Design flaws)
  • Cheap Parts
  • Warranty shipping cost more than the product

Comments

"I am currently on my 2nd of these joysticks, and I would not be on the 2nd except that it was a Christmas present. There are hundreds if not thousands of posts on the internet talking about a host of problems with this product. Knowing a bit about electronics I took mine apart to see if I could figure out what was causing them.

First: The Rheostats used in the joystick are so cheap you buy them by the pound. This means they are highly inaccurate and prone to dropouts (or infinity resistances). What this means to the end user is calibration problems, or joysticks that will not stay calibrated as the resistance just went outside the learned range.

Second: The Joystick has a reported problem of the 'twist' or 'rudder' not working after a while. This is the result of a design flaw in the rheostat assembly that allows a section of it to break off. Once broken you can forget any type of glue to fix it as it is hopeless. Recalibrate it, live with the limit, or throw it away.

Third: Replacing the Rheostats with good quality products is impossible, or mostly so. They are molded into the assemblies and there is not enough there to even work with on replacing them.

Overall View: Total trash, spend half the money on a no-named stick, that will live just as long, and consider your money well spent."
Did you find this review helpful? Yes  /  No

Midwinter

avatar
March 30, 2008
approved
reviewer
ProSCORE
0
negative
mixed
positive
0 pros
2 cons
have ithave it
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

Pros

Did not agree with any pros

Cons

  • Bad Design (Design flaws)
  • Stops functioning correctly after a period of time

Competitors

Midwinter prefers Saitek Cyborg Evo over Logitech Extreme 3D Pro
Did you find this review helpful? Yes  /  No

squalorking

avatar
December 31, 2007
approved
reviewer
ProSCORE
50
negative
mixed
positive
2 pros
2 cons

Pros

  • Comfortable grip for right handers
  • Nice button motion

Cons

  • Bad Design (Design flaws)
  • Cheap Parts

Comments

"Tis true, what Charon9 says. I really liked the way mine felt, but it lasted a month."
Did you find this review helpful? Yes  /  No

Twitter

- join or start the conversation

... Loading for latest tweets from search.twitter.com..

tweetie

Price comparison information by:

This product is also known as:

3, D, 3D