Samsung TL34HD

nominated for deletion on November 21 2008

This entry is a dupe of Samsung NV100HD (aka TL34HD).

Everything of value here should be transfered over, and a product title that better reflects both model numbers should be devised (I suggest one similar to the one on this product - Samsung NV100HD / TL34HD). Thoughts?

I definitely don't think it should be a delete, in fact I think it should be renamed to the original Samsung NV100HD. The first line of the summary can be explicit about its relationship with the TL34HD, but if you think about the way people search, they are likely to search for only the product name they know, not that it's a duplicate of another named product. This is similar to Wikipedia's disambiguation policy, instead of having a dedicated disambiguation page, we just have both products listed.

The biggest problem with this is the fact that people will add info to one report or the other. I just think it dilutes the usefulness, and isn't the right way to go about things. In my opinion it would be best if we could have 2 product reports that are really just one - like a forwarded wikipedia article.

Yes, I see what you're saying, but I still think we should have 2 reports simply for the reason that if people don't know it's the same product it will be confusing. To mitigate the problem of people adding information to both, perhaps we could go with the "series" format and have one report inherit from the other.

Let's sort this one out. My stance: 2 reports with their respective country-specific titles and them pointing to the other as a reference. We can make one (US version) more prominent but I don't think we should force anything. If people are searching and adding to the non-US version, that's fine by me.

in the fairness of keeping them separate there should actually be a third one created titled "VLUU NV100HD." Which is another name it goes by in Korea. lol. Well there is a difference and that is that the nv100hd comes with a cradle and remote that i guess is not included when  you buy it in the US.

 Can we removed the "DELETE" designation on this guy, since we seem to have sorted it out?